Ryland Gigante, Taylor McWilliams-Woods, Brandon Nelson, Gabriel Anderle, Jack Oleg, Helena Scholz-Carlson
The Village Theater Presents BOY MY GREATNESS Review - The Play and The Gender is The Thing
TLDR: A journey of identity and being yourself, Boy My Greatness frames this journey within the world of Shakespeare, one of the most famous gender-bending authors of all time. His acting troupe is up against a myriad of problems set out against them as well as within their own group, but they attempt to persevere so that the show will go on!
Gabriel Anderle, Jack Oleg, Helena Scholz-Carlson
We All Know Theatre Kids are Drama Queens
We are of the noble profession of acting.
To be on stage and performing is the greatest thrill for an actor. Some come to it later in life, and others know they were always destined for the stage. For those outside of the profession, there are mixed feelings. Is it truly a noble profession? Or is it an act of fancy? Or for some taking it to the extreme, is it engaging in an act of sin against God’s will? In the Village Theater’s production of Boy My Greatness we’re taken to the Renaissance era where Shakespeare’s theatre troupe deals with outside agitators, their own internal drama, and the looming threat of a plague all while questioning, is it all worth it?
And so we take our seats in the theater space at the Chicago Dramatists and know we’re in for a night of internal conflict and queer drama. The lights come up and we’re at The Globe as actors mill about the stage rehearsing lines. These are the King’s Men, Shakespeare’s acting troupe as they rehearse for their upcoming production of Antony and Cleopatra. As is tradition in their noble profession, all the women's parts are played by young men, sometimes even boys. Within their troupe, we meet a variety of characters and their relationships. Two teenagers have been inseparable since they were boys. One new member joining their company is a mere boy of 12 and has been acting since he was a babe. Another is in his early 20s, yet his career as the principal player of the lead women is almost at an end due to his mature age.
They each have their own conflicts within the troupe - competition, age, one that doesn’t want to be seen together with another man who dresses like a woman, and the unfortunate understanding of what a “patron” really expects. Then they also have to deal with a religious pest that keeps finding its way backstage trying to get them to see the error of their ways on the path of wickedness. And as if that wasn’t enough, there’s also the looming threat of a plague threatening to close their doors. It begs the question, will the show go on?
Gabriel Anderle
All The World’s A Stage…and The Rest is Drag
The world of this Renaissance play draws parallels to today. We know there was theatre recorded as far back as Ancient Greece, then we’re dropped here in the 1600s in another moment in time, and then we think about the art of entertainment today. It ranges from “traditional” stage plays to drag performances and it begs the question where does the performance end? Or rather, where does the awakening start?
Though Boy My Greatness is set in the past, everything about the play shows how history repeats itself and how we struggle through the same today. The ideas of gender and sexuality. How we present. How others think about us. How societal pressures impact living authentically.
And our actors, some gender-bending the roles themselves, give us captivating performances. We feel the camaraderie between them as they rehearse lines, fix each other’s costumes, and offer support and advice when needed. We feel their happiness when they’re in costume and the spotlight is on them as they recite Shakespeare’s words. And we feel their pain when one of their own might be lost to the plague. And though, no spoilers, things look like they may end tragically like any good Shakespeare play, the cast rounds out their performance with a defiant final number that has everyone in the audience on their feet applauding and cheering.
Helena Scholz-Carlson, Taylor McWilliams-Woods, Jack Oleg
The After Party Thoughts
Boy My Greatness is about finding the place that allows you to explore and be yourself and then frames it all in the world of the most famous gender-bending author of all time. It captures feelings and experiences many within the queer community will relate to and shows how even as history tends to repeat itself, this community will always find a way to bounce back.
For those that are looking for a show that has it all - plagues, drama, struggles with gender identity, internal and external conflict, and tons and tons of sass then Boy My Greatness would be an excellent match for you!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Helena Scholz-Carlson, Ryland Gigante, Jack Oleg
When
Now through November 22, 2026
Where
Chicago Dramatists
1105 W Chicago Ave.
Chicago, IL 60642
Runtime: 2hrs 15min, including an intermission
Tickets
$12+
Tickets can be purchased through The Village Theater website
Photos
Courtesy of The Village Theater
Find Allie and The After Party featured on Theatre in Chicago
Jack Oleg, Brandon Nelson, Helena Scholz-Carlson, Gabriel Anderle, Ryland Gigante
CAST
Gabe Anderle (Tom)
Ryland Gigante (Sam)
Brandon Nelson (John)
Helena Scholz-Carlson (Harry)
Jack Oleg (Hal)
Taylor McWilliams-Woods (Robin)
Aidan Henry (u/s Tom)
Cris King (u/s John)
Logan Martin (u/s Harry)
Castle (Dylan) McCumber (u/s Hal)
Gabriel McNabb (u/s Robin)
Jaden Tatge (u/s Sam)
CREATIVE
Zoe Senese-Grossberg (Playwright)
Emily Newmark (Director)
Claire Thompson (Assistant Director)
Alex Garcia (Stage Manager)
Francesca Butera (Assistant Stage Manager)
Alishiana Uyao (Technical Director)
Katelyn Montgomery (Scenic Designer)
Gina Montalvo (Sound Designer)
Maddy McKinney (Lighting Designer)
Lauren Holmes (Properties Designer)
Maggie McGlenn (Costume Designer)
Fiona Tyree (Costume Design Assistant)
Emily Waskowitz (Makeup & Hair Designer)
Naomi Zhanel Kalter (Dramaturg & Casting Director)
A.J. Paramo (Choreographer)
Evelyn Jane Wöhlbier (Intimacy Director)
Jesse James Hoover (Fight Coordinator)
Seth Wilson (Historical Consultant)
Clara Zucker (Producer)
Hannah Eisendrath (Producer)